SafeGradeAI
Independent Safety Certification

Not sure if an AI tool is safe for
your child
?

Independent safety ratings, privacy reviews, and age guidance for the AI tools your kids actually use — in 5 seconds.

Try:

Instant safety tier, score, & parent guidance for every tool we've reviewed.

  • Age-based safety ratings
  • Privacy & data collection reviews
  • Independent expert evaluations
  • Parent-friendly reports
  • School-ready assessments
Our Badges Keep Your Family Safe

Four safety badges. One simple answer.

Every AI tool is rated against our independent safety rubric and assigned one of four badges — so you know at a glance whether it's right for your child.

Free for FamiliesInstant DownloadNo Signup Required

The Family AI Safety Starter Pack — FREE!

$0.00$29— complimentary for every parent

A 12-page parent guide to evaluating, configuring, and supervising the AI tools your kids actually use. Built from the same independent framework we use to certify every product on SafeGradeAI.

By requesting the guide, you're subscribing to the SafeGradeAI newsletter — periodic safety alerts, blog updates, and occasional product offers. We never sell your data, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

PDF · 12 pages · ~380 KB · Free to share with families, schools, and PTAs.
SafeGradeAI
Updated 2026

Inside the Guide

  • Age-by-age AI readiness checklists (5–18)
  • 20 red flags every parent should know
  • A printable Family AI Agreement
  • Privacy-settings cheat sheet for top tools
  • 30 conversation starters by age group
  • A weekly 10-minute AI safety review routine

SafeGradeAI Certification

Understand What SafeGradeAI Ratings Mean

SafeGradeAI independently evaluates AI tools for age appropriateness, privacy, child safety, educational value, and transparency. Every certified tool falls into one of four tiers — so parents and schools know at a glance.

85–100

Strong privacy, robust safeguards, age-appropriate design.

75–84

Solid safety posture suitable for ages 9-12 with light oversight.

65–74

Acceptable for teens with active parental or school supervision.

Below 65

Significant safety, privacy, or moderation concerns.

Real evaluation — published May 2025

Character.AI scored 48/100 Not Recommended for anyone under 18

Open-ended AI companions with documented safety incidents and weak age verification.

NOT SAFEALL AGES
48
Out of 100
Overall safety score
Why it failed
  • Reported safety incidents
  • Weak age gating
  • Unbounded persona behavior
Privacy-first methodology
Independent reviewers
Trusted by educators
Built for families
Monitoring activeMethodology v2.5Standards Board verified
View safety updates

Featured

Recently certified AI tools

View all evaluations
KIDSAFEAGES 5–8

Khanmigo

Khan Academy · Tutoring

92
Score

An AI tutor built on a strict educational guardrail framework with strong privacy posture and parental oversight.

Ages 8–18School-safe
Monitoring activeMethodology v2.512 districts monitoring
Updated 1 yr agofreemium
KIDSAFEAGES 5–8

Duolingo Max

Duolingo · Language Learning

88
Score

AI roleplay features run in a narrowly scoped tutoring context with strong content guardrails.

Ages 10+School-safe
Monitoring activeMethodology v2.514 districts monitoring
Updated 1 yr agopaid
KIDSAFEAGES 5–8

MagicSchool

MagicSchool AI · Educator Tools

86
Score

Teacher-first AI suite with separate student-mode guardrails and district-level controls.

Ages TeachersSchool-safe
Monitoring activeMethodology v2.517 districts monitoring
Updated 1 yr agofreemium
New · AI-powered

AI Tool Analyzer

Type any AI tool — ChatGPT, Khanmigo, Character.AI, MagicSchool — and get a free SafeGradeAI safety report. Privacy risks, classroom guidance, parent advice, and school policy recommendations in seconds.

  • Overall safety rating and final verdict
  • Privacy & data risks (COPPA, FERPA, GDPR-K)
  • Classroom + parent + school policy guidance
AI Tool Analyzer illustration

What every evaluation includes

A consistent multi-step review for every certified tool

Every SafeGradeAI certification — from KidSafe Approved to Teen Approved — is produced from the same work streams. Findings are reproducible from the case file.

Privacy review

DPA review, data-flow mapping, retention defaults, and minor-data handling against FERPA, COPPA, GDPR-K, and AADC.

Moderation testing

Structured red-team sweep across 14 attack families, including persona jailbreaks, distress signals, and minor-likeness prompts.

Human verification

Two independent reviewers, senior sign-off, and a vendor right-of-reply before any tier is published.

Classroom readiness

Pedagogy fit, teacher tooling, age-band suitability, and integration with rostering and LMS platforms.

Compliance analysis

Per-jurisdiction alignment with state student-privacy laws, EU AI Act deployer obligations, and district policy norms.

Ongoing monitoring

Continuous policy watch with 72-hour disclosure triggers, downgrade watches, and scheduled annual re-reviews.

Live monitoring

Latest Safety Updates

Renewals, monitoring alerts, policy revisions, and new evaluations from the SafeGradeAI Monitoring Desk and Standards Board.

View the full feed

How scores are verified

Seven stages, from intake to ongoing monitoring

No SafeGradeAI tier is issued from an automated score alone. Every certification traces back to a documented review path.

  1. 01

    Submission & Intake

    Vendor submits a structured intake covering product surface area, intended audience, data flows, and existing safety documentation. Scoped before any review hours are spent.

  2. 02

    Documentation Review

    Two reviewers independently read the vendor's public and private documentation, comparing claims against the SafeGradeAI standard checklist.

  3. 03

    Safety Testing

    Reviewers run a standardized probe set across primary surfaces, including jailbreak, prompt-injection, self-harm, and age-bypass scenarios.

  4. 04

    Human Evaluation

    Educators and child-safety reviewers assess developmental fit, tone, and classroom usability in realistic K–12 scenarios.

  5. 05

    Verification

    Findings are cross-checked by a second senior reviewer. The vendor receives a draft report and 5 business days to provide clarifications.

  6. 06

    Certification Decision

    The Standards Committee issues a tier decision, public verification page, and downloadable report — tied to specific evidence in the case file.

  7. 07

    Ongoing Monitoring

    Certified products are tracked for policy changes, incidents, and feature updates. Material changes can trigger re-review between full cycles.

How it works

A rigorous, transparent process

Step 1

We evaluate

Independent reviewers assess each AI tool across privacy, moderation, safeguards, design, and transparency.

Step 2

We certify

Tools receive an independent certification tier from KidSafe to Not Recommended based on our comprehensive safety assessment.

Step 3

You decide

Parents and schools use our certifications to confidently choose AI that fits their values and needs.

Trust infrastructure

Why schools and families trust SafeGradeAI

SafeGradeAI was built to be the independent governance layer for educational AI — evidence-driven, framework-based, and accountable between reviews.

Independent evaluations

Reviews are conducted by SafeGradeAI's research team with no commercial relationship to the vendors under review. Findings are scored against a published framework, not a vendor brief.

Framework-driven analysis

Every certification follows the same five-dimension framework: privacy, moderation, age appropriateness, transparency, and educational alignment. Scores are weighted for use by minors.

Human-reviewed certifications

Two reviewers independently evaluate each product, with senior sign-off and a vendor right-of-reply before a tier is published. No tier is issued from an automated score alone.

Ongoing monitoring

Certifications are tracked continuously for policy changes, incidents, and material updates. Status can be paused, downgraded, or revoked between annual reviews.

Public transparency

Every certified product has a public verification page with its score, last review date, methodology version, and monitoring status. Findings are reproducible from the case file.

Education-specific standards

Reviews are aligned to COPPA, FERPA, GDPR-K, and the UK Age Appropriate Design Code, and tested against scenarios drawn from K–12 classrooms and family use.

Built for

One framework, four constituencies

SafeGradeAI is designed to be useful to the people who actually decide how AI shows up in classrooms and homes — and to the vendors who build it.

Parents

Why they use it
Clear, jargon-free guidance on which AI tools are safe for children — and at what age.
What they get
Family briefings, supervision recommendations, and a verified directory you can trust.
What it solves
Replaces guesswork and marketing claims with an independent safety record.

Schools

Why they use it
A consistent framework for evaluating AI tools across classrooms, grade bands, and devices.
What they get
Sample reports, classroom guidance, and policy templates teachers can deploy this week.
What it solves
Eliminates per-school re-evaluation and gives teachers procurement-grade evidence.

Districts

Why they use it
An independent governance layer for AI procurement, FERPA review, and ongoing monitoring.
What they get
Verified tiers, DPA-ready documentation, and monitoring alerts between annual reviews.
What it solves
Reduces vendor-review cycle time and supports defensible procurement decisions.

AI Vendors

Why they use it
A credible, third-party path to demonstrate education readiness to school buyers.
What they get
Public verification page, badge usage rights, and a clear remediation channel.
What it solves
Replaces ad-hoc trust pages with a recognized certification recognized by districts.
Go deeper · One-time $29

The Complete AI Safety Blueprint

The 28-page deep-dive companion to the free Starter Pack. Everything you need to confidently lock down, monitor, and talk about AI used by students — built from the same independent framework we use to certify every tool on SafeGradeAI.

Get the Ultimate AI Safety Guide — $29One-time payment · Instant PDF · Lifetime updates

What's included

  • Age-by-age action plans for ages 5–18
  • Tool lockdown guides: ChatGPT, Gemini, companion AIs
  • Scripts for the hardest AI conversations with your kids
  • Printable Family AI Agreement (signable)
  • Weekly 10-minute safety review system
  • Lifetime updates as new tools launch

AI Is Moving Fast. Stay Informed.

Bi-weekly insights on AI tools, student safety, privacy, and education trends — so you can make confident decisions for children and teens.

By subscribing you agree to receive emails from SafeGradeAI. You can unsubscribe at any time.