Quick safety summary
MagicSchool at a glance
78/100
tween
Ages K-12 (under-13 via school)
Within intended range
High
Score 88/100
82/100
Strong filters
Best use cases
- AI Education Platform (K-12) workflows
- Classroom assignments
Main risks
- No elevated risks identified.
Recommended for
Not ideal for
Product overview
How MagicSchool works
MagicSchool AI is a purpose-built K-12 AI platform offering 80+ teacher tools and 50+ MagicStudent tools with genuine privacy infrastructure: SOC 2 Type II, iKeepSafe FERPA/COPPA certification, and a 95% Common Sense Privacy rating earned March 2026. Student-mode requires school or teacher provisioning, keeps moderation always on, and explicitly prohibits LLM training on student data. A June 2026 Broward County School Board debate is a real-world caution flag that governance processes must accompany the technology.
Student usage
Via MagicStudent inside teacher-created student rooms with curated tool access
Modality
Text-based generative AI
Underlying model
Multiple third-party LLMs (specific providers not publicly disclosed)
Common use cases
- Lesson planning and differentiation
- Writing feedback and assessment creation
- IEP and communication drafting
- Student tutoring and writing in teacher-controlled rooms
- Teacher professional development
Free full report — 0 of 3 used
You can open 3 complete evaluations on the free plan. Already-opened reports stay unlocked. Upgrade to School Pro for unlimited full reports and the K-12 governance workspace.
Risk intelligence
Risk level breakdown
Risk dimensions derived directly from the SafeGradeAI rubric scores (higher score = higher risk). Additional dimensions appear when entered by an evaluator.
Scores derived from the SafeGradeAI rubric. Methodology: read more.
Safety framework
Framework analysis
Five evaluation categories from the SafeGradeAI rubric. Each shows the rubric score, evaluator confidence, and (where documented) analysis, strengths, and concerns.
Strengths & concerns
Detailed pros & concerns
Strengths
- 95% Common Sense Privacy rating (March 2026) — one of the highest in K-12 edtech
- SOC 2 Type II and iKeepSafe FERPA/COPPA certifications
- Student data explicitly excluded from LLM training
- MagicStudent requires teacher room-code or SSO — no open sign-up
- Always-on bidirectional moderation in student mode
- Real-time teacher/admin alerts for self-harm or violence
- Centralized district admin dashboards with tool approval workflows
Concerns
- Broward County School Board paused rollout (June 2026) over privacy and governance
- Advanced moderation customization is enterprise-tier only
- COPPA consent delegated entirely to schools
- UK/international deployment concerns re: DfE guidance alignment
- No publicly available independent red-team results
- Cookie and device identifier collection persists for children
Guidance at a glance
Recommendations for parents, teachers, and administrators
Parent guidance
Your child will only encounter MagicSchool AI through a teacher-assigned classroom. The platform expressly forbids selling your child's data or using it for advertising, and AI providers are contractually barred from training on student content. However, MagicSchool relies on the school to provide COPPA consent for under-13 users, so your school should be your first point of contact. Check whether your district has signed a Data Processing Agreement.
Classroom-use recommendation
Approved for teacher use districtwide and for student-facing MagicStudent rooms with active bidirectional moderation enabled; require every room to have a monitored keyword list and a named teacher owner. Do not let students use it without a room code or SSO.
School policy recommendation
Before deploying district-wide: execute the standard DPA and verify state student privacy law coverage; establish a written parental notice and consent workflow for under-13 students; determine whether your plan tier provides enterprise-level moderation controls; configure moderation sensitivity; develop a board-level AI governance policy. The Broward pause illustrates that absent such documentation, community concerns can halt even well-intentioned programs.
Trust & credibility
Evaluation integrity
Last reviewed
June 29, 2026
Report version
v1
Evaluator confidence
80/100
Monitoring
Active continuous monitoring
Methodology
Scored against the SafeGradeAI rubric covering privacy, moderation, generative safeguards, age-appropriate design, and transparency.
Read full methodology →Change log
- June 29, 2026Evaluation published.
Re-tested at least every 6 months and after any major release.
What changed since the previous evaluation
Reviewed June 29, 2026 · Confidence: high
- 2023-05: MagicSchool AI founded by Adeel Khan
- 2023-09: Public launch of teacher tool suite
- 2024: Student-mode ("MagicStudent") launched with teacher monitoring and content filters
- 2025: Adopted by more than 4,000 US school districts
- 2026-03-19: Common Sense Privacy score of 95% published
- 2026-05: Agentic moderation update reports 3x reduction in false positives
- 2026-06: Broward County School Board temporarily pauses use pending review
Sources & citations
Every major claim in this evaluation is backed by at least one credible public source. Last reviewed June 29, 2026.
- 1Student Data PolicyMagicSchool · 2025-02-06 · magicschool.ai
- 2Privacy Evaluation for MagicSchool.ai — 95%Common Sense Privacy · 2026-03-12 · privacy.commonsense.org
- 3MagicSchool Earns 95% Privacy RatingMagicSchool · 2026-03-19 · magicschool.ai
- 4MagicSchool — FERPA and COPPA Product ProfileiKeepSafe · 2024-09 · ikeepsafe.org
- 5How AI Moderation Keeps Students SafeMagicSchool · 2025-05-21 · magicschool.ai
- 6Broward School Board to Weigh AI PauseSouth Florida Sun Sentinel · 2026-06-22 · sun-sentinel.com
- 7Broward School Board Pauses Rollout of AI PlatformCBS News Miami · 2026-06-23 · cbsnews.com
- 8Trust, Data Protection & Privacy for SchoolsMagicSchool · 2026 · magicschool.ai
Methodology
How this score was produced
Scored against the SafeGradeAI framework v2.5 across five dimensions — privacy, moderation, GenAI safeguards, age-appropriate design, and transparency — with COPPA, FERPA, and GDPR-K lenses. Independent. No vendor pay-for-rating.
Independent evaluation. SafeGradeAI does not accept payment from vendors for ratings.
Official website
Visit MagicSchool directly
For the most current product capabilities, pricing, and policies, visit the official Magic School, Inc. website.
magicschool.ai